Ted sits down with Libby Clark, Founder of Libby Clark Law, to discuss how AI is accelerating change across the legal industry and exposing longstanding challenges in law firm culture, leadership, and attorney well-being. From overcoming resistance to change to developing the human skills that technology cannot replace, Libby shares her expertise in legal practice, organizational transformation, and attorney well-being. As trad
Libby Clark is a practicing lawyer who advises midsized companies and has worked extensively in real estate development. She is also a leader in attorney well-being and served as co-chair of the New York State Attorney Well-Being Task Force and as the first chair of New York’s Standing Committee on Attorney Well-Being.
The Future of Law Depends on Skills AI Can’t Replace
Libby Clark, thank you for joining me today.
Thank you so much for having me. I’m excited.
Yeah, I’m excited too. You came highly recommended by Anastasia, who’s one of my favorite people in the industry.
Same.
When she told me that we needed to chat, I jumped on it.
Thank you.
And here we are. So, where do we start? With an intro? Can you tell us a little bit about who you are, what you’re doing, and where you do it?
Libby Clark: Sure. I’m currently general counsel and legal strategist to midsized companies. That’s where I’ve landed these days.
But I’ve been in practice for about 22 years. I spent most of my time in real estate development in New York, hanging out in those rooms. Throughout that process, I guess I would say, on a dual track, I became very interested—after the loss of one of my colleagues, probably in my second year of practice, to addiction—in attorney well-being.
What drew me to attorney well-being was looking at the attrition factor in the practice and asking why people were leaving, why it was happening to certain people and not others. But mostly, what it really taught me was the indifference to the suffering that was going on.
We had all just lost this associate. We all knew, but no one discussed it. It was looked at as a personal failing. Yet I was out to dinner with colleagues, and I was talking to young lawyers. I knew we weren’t the only ones who were suffering. He was just the one who fell apart, right?
Host: Outwardly.
Libby Clark: But inwardly, there was a lot of pain and suffering. I was just mystified by the indifference.
That tends to be, as I look back over 22 years, what always mystifies me: Why do people not care? Why do we drive by the accident scene? How come we can’t stop and look at this problem?
That led me into the attorney well-being journey. I ended up being the co-chair of the New York State Attorney Well-Being Task Force in 2021, which did a landmark report that was adopted by the House in 2022.
Host: I think I may have made years there, right?
Libby Clark: And then I became the first chair of the Standing Committee on Attorney Well-Being in New York.
So I had the rough-and-tumble world of real estate development alongside what I thought at the time was the warm-and-fuzzy world of attorney well-being. That’s where I find myself today.
It didn’t occur to me, I think probably until the last eight years, how much AI was really going to begin to touch and concern the attorney well-being issue—that things were going to accelerate faster and problems were going to happen even faster.
That’s when I got really, really interested in technology’s impact on the human.
Host: So are you of the opinion that the well-being situation becomes more dire as a result of AI, or less?
Libby Clark: I think it depends on how we hold it. It’s like the same thing in your industry. You can slap a tool onto a firm, but unless it’s integrated into workflow in a way that’s meaningful and measurable, it just doesn’t matter.
Well-being is sort of the same way, just from a different angle. You can slap on tools, workshops, and benefits packages, but if the underlying systems are still damaging, all you’re going to do with AI is make those systems faster.
That’s my take on the article I wrote for the State Bar, which is about racing to operationalize intelligence, but not wisdom. You can make certain things faster; it just doesn’t mean that you’re not still building on a faulty premise or faulty system.
My argument is that we have not corrected the things that the task force found.
Host: Yeah. There are lots of takes on the future of Big Law as it relates to being post-transformation. There are dystopian, utopian, and, I think, middle-of-the-road views, which is where I land.
I think there’s going to be a significant amount of reshuffling and reshaping within Big Law—not just in how the work gets done, but in the size and shape of the industry.
Honestly, if you really look at the metrics, Big Law is one of the most fragmented industries on the planet. My listeners have heard me talk a lot about the combined revenues of the Am Law 200. It’s about $200 billion. The Big Four combined is about $240 billion.
Four Big Four companies exceed the revenue of 200 law firms. If you look at market concentration, an industry is considered fragmented when one firm does not control 5% of the market. The closest is Kenney, at about 2.5%.
And Kenney is an extreme outlier.
Libby Clark: It is.
Host: It’s highly fragmented, and AI is, I believe, going to be a consolidating force in the industry.
So much of the industry is reliant, at least here in the U.S., on partner capital to fund the transformation. You were talking about change earlier and the different dimensions of change. It’s not just the technology—the technology by itself is significant—but also organizational change.
I saw a great article the other day that said, “Your org chart is your transformation strategy.”
Libby Clark: Oh, nice. Yeah.
Host: I was like, “Oh, that’s so good.” I’m trying to get that guy on the podcast.
But I do believe that to be true. You can buy the best technology in the world, but how you align and empower your organization, resource it, and set the tone at the top is going to dictate success or failure. It’s not going to be your technology.
Libby Clark: Inside a change-resistant profession.
Host: Highly resistant.
Libby Clark: One of the takeaways from the task force report—and we did have clinical advisors on the task force—was that we heard from both the legal-industrial side and the psychological side.
For reasons that I will not go into here, lawyers are trained toward pessimism. We’re trained against change. We’re presidential in our behavior.
Host: Presidential?
Libby Clark: I mean resistant in our behavior.
So you combine all of those things with everything you just said, and it’s almost like a perfect storm for ostriching—sticking our heads down in the sand while our butts are exposed. No offense to any of your listeners, but that’s essentially the strategy of those types of characteristics.
If you’re a person listening to this right now and you see those behaviors around you, I want people to understand that it’s happening because of the culture of law.
Be heads-up when you’re seeing that, because it’s not a change strategy. It’s an avoidance strategy, and it’s deeply embedded in the profession.
Host: It truly is. I often cite Dr. Larry Richards’ work.
Libby Clark: Yeah, that’s Larry’s course.
Host: Empathy and resilience are well below the mean in the average attorney personality profile. Those are two really important characteristics when it comes to change and transformation: empathy, understanding how the person on the other side of the table feels; and resilience, fighting through resistance.
We have not only some cultural work to do, but maybe some work as individuals.
Libby Clark: Oh, no question. Having sat at partnership tables, I think the part that makes us dangerous to ourselves is the ability to make arguments so cogently, so tightly, and so wrongly that we stay stuck.
We’re great at it, right? We dismiss, minimize, and rationalize. We’re trained. We are literally trained to make arguments.
But when those arguments are used to stay stuck, they become a detriment to us.
I want people who sense change coming, who sense that there is a new way on the horizon—and they’re right—to understand that when they see that kind of stuckness around them, it’s not only cultural; it’s something to tilt against. It’s something to go at, even when it’s hard, because not doing so leaves the structure and the profession in jeopardy when it could be iterating toward its own success.
Host: Yeah. I’m reading a book right now. Well, I’m actually listening on Audible because I hate reading. I fall right asleep, so I listen instead.
It’s called *Zone to Win*, by Geoffrey Moore. He was the author of *Crossing the Chasm*. He talks about how difficult it is and cites dozens of case studies showing how difficult it is.
That book was written over ten years ago, and the rate of change looked modest compared to what we’re facing right now. He lists all these case studies of companies that fought unsuccessfully against the innovator’s dilemma, where you’ve got a profitable business with an existing supply chain, stakeholders, employees, customers, culture, and ways of doing business.
The amount of resources you have to carve out of what is today a very productive and profitable path—the slice of the pie chart that you have to allocate to change—is significant, like more than 20%.
Building consensus within an organization—in this case, a partnership within the partnership—to divert more than a fifth of your resources toward disrupting your existing model that’s printing money and setting record profits every year is a really tough proposition.
Few firms can do it. If you stack on top of that all of the industry’s cultural baggage, it’s tough.
Libby Clark: Well, and you also have the relative generational impact of those decisions in a business on a cash basis.
If you layer on top of that the fact that you’re not aligned in a governance structure for the future of the firm—and I’m not saying that’s everybody—but let’s say that is your situation. Then you have stakeholders, and probably a sizeable equity voting percentage, that have no desire to divert 20% in the last three years of practice. They have no interest. There’s no incentive for them to do that.
So we’re hoping for their altruistic desire to bolster a firm into a future that they don’t plan to be at. You have these very structural incentives that run counter to one another.
I advise a lot of corporations. That’s a lot of what I do. Advising corporate behavior is slightly different from advising partnership behavior in firms, for reasons that I think you and I both understand intuitively.
Because we’re all not growing in the same direction for the future of the company, we’re growing in the direction of the practice that we have built.
I say “we” because I’m a practicing lawyer. I know what it’s like to build your own book, to be proud of it, and to be able to take it with you wherever you go.
I also work inside companies, so I know what a liability that mindset can be.
Host: For sure. Everything has really stacked up to encourage a lone-wolf mindset. Rule 5.6 enables you to take your book and walk across the street to the other firm.
We jokingly call Big Law “a hotel for lawyers” because it’s not always a sticky relationship. It’s a glorified revenue or overhead-sharing scheme.
Libby Clark: Because of the rule that you mentioned, which has its downsides, it has its upsides, too. But I think, again, naming something for what it is isn’t being critical.
Naming something for what it is allows choice. It allows awareness. We can say, “Hey, Rule 5.6, having our own book, being self-interested—that’s who we are.” That’s just naming it.
How is it affecting us? Can we have a robust discussion about whether all the shadow sides of this are something we’ve thought about and dealt with?
I don’t think naming something is necessarily being critical. I think it gives us a lot of opportunity to say, “I’ve never had to think about this before. In a time of this sort of change, maybe I should.”
Host: Agreed. I’ve heard a funny metaphor one time: law firms are like hair salons. You get Sarah, who cuts my hair. I could care less whether she’s at Salon Lofts or some other booth place down the street. When COVID happened and she started cutting hair in her garage, guess where I went? To the garage.
The dynamic runs deeper than just within the law firms themselves. It’s in the whole law firm–client relationship. You make significant investments in your legal partners, in the people, and over time those relationships get sticky.
Libby Clark: Yeah. I think the reason you like Sarah is because you come in and complain about your dog or whatever it is, and Sarah is super empathetic and listens to you. She cuts great hair, too.
It’s the whole experience that you enjoy, right? That’s the thing I think we forget.
When I was writing for the State Bar about the difference between operational intelligence and wisdom, this is what I’m talking about. Remembering that output isn’t labor. We’re never going to do output faster than the machine can.
But the experience of being in the chair, having Sarah listen to us, and understanding that we would follow her even to her garage is the thing we should be focusing on, training on, and explaining: how those lawyers are able to produce that kind of stickiness.
It’s human skills. It’s skills that involve listening, empathy, all the things that you listed a minute ago, and the ability to apply that to wisdom and pattern recognition.
If we’re not producing a way to train the Sarahs, then we just have robots that can cut hair.
Host: And is there sufficient emphasis on that today? It seems like the lawyers who are good at it either inherently possess some skills that others don’t, or they learn on the job. It doesn’t seem like there’s a lot of focus in law school on those sorts of things.
Libby Clark: I think that’s the tragedy. The more I talk to lawyers about this subject, essentially I find myself talking to the outlaws, so to speak—the people who have left the legal-industrial complex, as I’ve come to call it.
The profession, like many professions, is both art and science. It is both.
It’s both for medicine. It’s that for law.
But because of the feeder system and the way that the culture and the legal-industrial complex developed—and this is just my take from being in law schools—the skills that were taught were the ones that were helpful for output and production-line work, because that’s what firms were hiring for at the time.
If my theory is right—I’m not sure that it is—but if it is, that operational output is going to be far more productive using machines.
Then what’s left for a lawyer?
Those are the things that I think we’re woefully behind on in law schools.
Host: We continue.
Libby Clark: I just read an article—I don’t remember which law school, and it doesn’t matter—that is banning the use of AI for a year. Is that a good decision or a bad decision?
You’re going to train them in all this operational output that they’re never going to do. I just don’t know that we’re thinking high enough or broadly enough.
It’s sort of the Potter Stewart standard: “I know it when I see it.” I know the lawyers who have that thing, who can do that. That’s something that makes them sticky.
Should we find out what that is?
As a broad concept, understand that what people are going to be paying for is essentially cultivated wisdom. Have we ever asked ourselves how we get there? How does a lawyer obtain that?
I call them analog lawyers. I’m an analog lawyer, meaning I can remember the books in the library. I’m one of the last generations of a fully analog lawyer.
I’ll benefit from this digitized world because I can use my analog knowledge and the benefits of the tools. But if I’m 20 years younger and I don’t have analog training, how are we going to get the lawyers who can exercise that kind of wisdom?
Here’s my other concern with this pace of AI: The decisions that are going to be handed to lawyers are going to have more gravity, weight, and importance than ever before. We don’t know how to train wisdom.
I look at it as a slow-moving storm. Is it possible to train wisdom? What would that look like? That’s the question we should be asking.
Host: It has to be possible, right?
Libby Clark: If we go all the way back, that doesn’t mean I have all the answers, but I think it is possible because, prior to law schools, we had a very robust apprenticeship program. That was how lawyers became lawyers: through a deep apprenticeship.
I believe we were a guild profession all the way back. If you think about that history, it was about watching, doing, and being immersed in the work.
In some ways, I believe we offloaded that responsibility to law schools for reasons that make a lot of sense. I’m not suggesting otherwise.
But the profit of having someone just follow you around and watch you doesn’t make sense inside the legal-industrial complex. It makes sense in a profession, but it doesn’t make sense in that system.
So I think there we again find the schism that’s starting to happen about what really makes the profession. And I think about it with the—
When did surgery become part of the medical profession? If I looked at the history of that, versus what we're considered—healers—you're really starting to see us in our profession begin to unpack the difference between someone who is practicing the profession and someone who's putting out output. I think we're going to cut along that line.
Yeah, you know, I hate to sound so doom and gloom here, but I think there's a lot of—to your point—the goal is not to be critical. The goal is to lay everything out on the table and figure out, let's have the hard conversations.
Agreed.
I wrote a post a while back, and it was “The 10 Sacred Cows That Have to Be Sacrificed,” but I added another one, so they're now 11. I'll just read through them really quickly.
Yeah.
These are the sacred cows that have to be slaughtered to come out the other side of this transformation successfully.
Performance metrics have to be changed. Top-line metrics don't make sense in an AFA scenario.
The billable hour: it's not just pricing; it's part of lawyer identity.
Business professionals: they have to be properly empowered, recruited, and centrally trained, and have the appropriate seats at the table.
The apprenticeship model that we just talked about.
Yes.
Systems and data. Today, Big Law spends 2.4%. That's half what accounting and consulting—the closest adjacent industries—spend.
Incentive structures, cash basis, we talked about the partnership model, decision rights, transparency, client transparency.
And then the eleventh one I added that I want to riff on for just a minute is go-to-market. Law firms historically have not had to think about go-to-market very much, not like a traditional business. It's like, my go-to-market is, I go get the best people that can originate new business and deliver amazing outcomes. And that's my go-to-market.
Now we're entering into an era where go-to-market is going to mean so much. In fact, when AI really started to break loose in the beginning, my thinking was, you know, whatever has the best data is really going to have a huge advantage. And I have shifted away from that. I don't think data is going to be the differentiator. I think it's going to be necessary, but not sufficient.
What I do think is going to be a big differentiator is how firms build the learning loops and capture the knowledge and wisdom within their practice, and how they package and price those products and services in alignment with market expectations.
That's a newer insight. What made me come to that insight was when I realized that the delta between Kirkland and Latham's data is not going to move the dial. You don't need an endless corpus of data to train AI. In fact, 50 or 60 examples is plenty.
So my thinking has evolved on what's going to make the difference. I don't know—what are your thoughts on the different issues?
I've so much here.
You know, part of it is, I do not profess to be a technology expert. In fact, that's probably the last thing anyone should look to me for. But what I am really, really interested in is human design and how humans design systems.
Right.
And so tech impacts that. What I would say about my thinking is data—one of the things we know about the collection of data, and this comes from an adjacent industry, but really the tech industry—is that data will always be backward-looking. Always. It has to be. It's based upon history.
Okay, and there is a certain amount of probability that that history will repeat again, but there's also a high probability that it won't. And so when you understand that, what you're really saying is, I have the best backward-looking rearview mirror, but I don't have my headlights on.
So, you know, I'm not trying to be difficult here, but it's the headlight conversation that we need to be having.
When you talk about go-to-market, I'm really fascinated by that, because what it's saying is, I've stopped looking in the rearview. I understand that a whole bunch of attorney wisdom and judgment is the ability to take the backward-looking and project it forward.
Right?
That's a skill. And there's no AI on the planet that I'm aware of yet that can do that, right? Because it's all based on everything that's happened. It's not, to the best of my knowledge, a fortune teller yet.
Right.
Because it's based on everything we've done. So that still means that all the future work to be done will be done by humans, because that's our talent—our headlights.
So when you talk about go-to-market, firms won't be selling talent alone. That's true. The talent that you follow, that lawyer that you went with, whatever, has to both have the rearview and look forward.
So when you say, how do we market that into the future? You're saying we have both the data—that's the backward-looking—and we understand how to value that. We understand how to price that. And we have the best forward-looking strategic operators that you can imagine, because we've trained them as humans to do the work of forward-looking.
That's where I think the market conversation will begin, as opposed to what it's been up until now, which is, to use a normal name here, everybody goes to Bob for M&A because Bob's the M&A guy. That was our marketing strategy.
Okay, well, those days are over.
Yeah.
Love you, Bob, but if it takes you three times as much money and three times as long, you're about to lose market share to a faster, better, more efficient model. That's something we've never faced before. That's why go-to-market is so important. The market you're entering is not the one Bob came from.
Right. You know, I would even take it a step further and say that lawyers aren't the best people to figure this out.
Really?
Yeah, and I'll tell you why. I'll give you an example. There's some data that supports my position on this.
My listeners have heard me refer to the Deloitte report that came out in June. It surveyed 120 in-house legal leaders and asked them questions like, “What percentage of your law firms—your panel—have had meaningful conversations with you about how AI is going to affect the economics of the relationship?”
Almost 70% said, “We've only had an initial conversation or no conversation at all.”
So what that tells me, reflecting on that as I have, is lawyers are paid to come prepared, to be right, and not necessarily to be vulnerable. As a software CEO, I don't have those tendencies.
So I go to customers all the time and go, “Hey, look, I don't have this figured out, but I think there's a problem that you have that I can help you solve.” And I create what's called a design-partner relationship.
So I partner with a firm or firms, and they help me understand the problem. We iterate together on a solution, and in return for the time that they invest, they get a significant discount on the licensing when the thing is fully baked.
Law firms don't know—they don't understand how that works. And that is what's not happening right now: design partnerships around pricing and the economics.
And it's what law firm clients want. They want to be engaged. They don't want law firms to go into a vacuum, into a closed-door meeting, and push this nice, neat package together that's, you know, with a bow on it, and come and present it.
That's not what they want. They want to understand, because they're immediately going to poke holes in it. If they help design it, they will support it, they will embrace it, and we're not unhappy.
So my point in all that is, there are concepts where you're just selling people's time. Lawyers in leadership, I think, are a totally fine proposition. It's not that complicated. The business of law is not complicated. The practice of law is very complicated; the business of law, not so much.
And now we're entering into an era where firms are going to have to take risks, they're going to have to make capital investments, and they're going to have to understand go-to-market strategies and the trade-offs inherent in decision-making around that. And that's probably not—
And do you want Bob in the room talking about that?
Right.
No offense to Bob. There is no— but you know what I mean?
There is an old adage in my family that the tools that bring you here aren't going to be the ones that launch you, right? The tools that you use to get to where you are—congratulations, good. I'm glad you're in the position to talk about reinvestment of capital. Those are excellent things.
But there is a moment where you really have to say—and this is tough for lawyers—am I the best person to be iterating this or to be thinking about this?
I remember when I was in a law firm partnership, and we were talking about something very simple, like redoing our website. This was over 15 years ago, maybe 16 years ago. I don't know. And I had the novel and insane idea of hiring somebody who writes marketing copy to write our bios instead of us.
It was like I had launched a rock through the window. Like, “What is—?” And this is such a simple concept compared to what you're talking about, right? It took me to arm-wrestle the older partners to the ground—the more senior partners, excuse me—in order to get a marketing person to write the marketing copy, because we don't know how to write that.
And I had to reassure them, “I know we're great writers, guys. I know we're all really good writers. It's not about that, right? It's that we don't have the thing that we need to attract client attention.”
So you're saying essentially the same thing, but on a macro scale. And it takes a lot of humility to say, “I might not be the person,” right? And I might be at an end, and I need to be okay in iteration. I need to be okay in discovery with a partner I trust, which would be your company.
Right? I trust. That's where trust comes in, right? And you're in an industry, I think, where you could, if you wanted to, give everybody a package and just bolt it on and say, “Thank you, here's your fee, and here's everything. I'll figure it out for you,” knowing it will break.
But that's not the style, and that's not a deliverable, and that's not how you want to do it.
So it's like, how do you get them to a place to understand that it is a trust-based partnership of discovery?
Yeah.
And I have such a hard time envisioning how the transition would work where we're bringing in professional management, right? Like, a proper CEO who understands how to pull the market and understand market expectations, build offerings, where to take risk and in what capacity and to what extent, capital strategy, right?
I mean, if you're just funding everything out of partner capital, great if you're Kirkland. If you're anyone else, good luck, especially if you're in the Am Law Second Hundred, right? Not so easy.
All of those sorts of things—somebody who's done it, who's got the resume, been there, got the T-shirt—pulling someone like that in and enabling—
There are a few examples of this.
I was going to say, there's a couple of firms that did this and did it well.
Well, who really had a professional—I believe the professional CEOs had a legal background, but they weren't practicing anymore. In other words, they spoke the language.
Yeah.
But I know it's happened and it's gone well for those firms. But you're right, it is the outlier, not the norm.
Yeah, exactly. And how do we transition into an era where it is the norm?
Because again, if I'm right—which, who knows, maybe I am, maybe I'm not—but if the go-to-market piece is as critical in the success of the post-transformation world, if that ends up being true, who's going to be best positioned to capitalize? Is it going to be those who brought in external DNA and thought differently about these problems? Or is it going to be the firms that have leadership who got there by being the best at lawyering?
I think it's going to be the firms that do the one thing that we are so loath to do, which is focus on what our clients want.
Okay, so we focus on what we want and how we've practiced and how we've set up our industry and our rules and our ethics. We are one of the most inwardly focused professions.
So before I launched my practice two years ago, almost a year ago, I went out and interviewed 50 CEOs, and I asked them the same 10 questions about how they procure legal services and what they hate about it.
For those that didn't see it in my background, I've also been a COO of a large company. So I started as a general counsel. I was promoted to chief operating officer. So I've actually run the P&L. I've done the inside track, and I've hired legal services. And so I understand what it felt like from the client side.
And it is brutal.
I was standing in a room full of, I think—it was managing partners in New York City last spring. And I asked them, “When was the last time that you invited your largest client on the golf outing?” And all the hands went up.
I said, “When was the last time you were invited on the golf outing for one of your companies?” About 25% of the hands went up.
This was the outcome. I won't get into the details of what my CEO survey showed, which is they hate how we do business. They hate how we do business.
Yeah.
Okay. So when we talk about picking our head up out of the sand, one of the things that we have to come to grips with is how disliked we are for our business practices—for the legal industrial complex. We are not liked for it.
That doesn't mean that we're doing anything wrong. It doesn't mean it's a criticism. It means that I think the firms that are going to win are going to go to market client-focused.
Yes.
That's what I'm saying.
Yes.
And yes, it will be uncomfortable internally.
Yes, it's going to be a whole culture shift.
Yes, you're going to have to recruit and train and have different performance metrics.
Yes, all of that is going to stink, and yet you still want the date.
So you're going to have to do the things that make you dateable, right? Because the monopoly is ending.
Yes, that's a great point.
I mean, go-to-market is inherently customer-focused. That's my whole point. The market is the company.
And so LinkedIn—I go on there, and again, I read it, and most of the conversation is inwardly focused. What happens to the hours? What happens inside? How are we going to build the tech? Everything is internal.
And so little of the conversation is about what our clients want to experience in this new—
Under number 10, under client transparency. But I think that that is what they're going to ask—or I know, because I did the interviews.
They're going to ask you, and I encourage everyone not to think that being offended is going to work anymore. Like, if you say, “I'm not worth that? You don't think I'm worth that?” You may be, but why don't you know how to say it?
Oh, because you were never trained to say what your value is. Well, today's the day.
So go-to-market means you're going to name and defend your value in a way that is transparent to your client. And you're going to say it with feeling, and you're going to mean it, because you think you have the best product on the market.
And the product is the company behind you. And that company happens to be a law firm. But that training doesn't exist.
Indeed.
Yeah.
And what's interesting is, I'm not a believer that the billable hour is going away anytime soon. I don't believe that to be the case. But what I do believe is that the AFA slice of the pie chart, which today is 10% to 15%, depending on who you ask, is going to grow.
I think in fairly short order—in 2027, we're going to see a lot more value-based work.
I just think we have to look at the numbers in the UK and Australia. I mean, there are leaders on this. We can just look around.
There are things that make it harder for us right now—not harder, more of a barrier to moving at the pace that happens overseas—is our jurisdictional structure. We have 50 states, 50 bars, the federal bar—we have more than 50 bars. My point is that our regulatory structure, with the differing ethics rules across the country, makes consolidation of AFAs harder. It just does.
But that doesn't mean it's not coming. It just means we're slower because we have some institutional or structural issues in the way.
That's coming.
So I'm not a believer in anything in the extreme. Do I think that there are still going to be files for the rest of our lives where time plus a value equals what the fee is going to be?
Yeah, that's going to stay. And it's going to stay for a certain slice of practices where it makes sense.
But when I'm meeting with law firms and we're talking about it from the operational, COO, finance, and reinvestment standpoint, you need to be able to identify those line items within your practice or your practice areas— which ones are going to be AFA-proof. What are the ones that we really think are going to stay hourly? And then all the other ones—
Where we can begin to figure out how—I mean, law firms have 20, 30, 40 years of data that they can pull from to say, “Okay, how long does it take me to get to a bill of particulars? How long does it take me to get to depositions? How long does it take me?” We could run these numbers if we wanted to, and begin to quantify how AI helps us pick up the efficiencies and where to reinvest that.
But that’s operational finance, and I don’t see a lot of lawyers sort of versed in that. That makes sense. So that’s my issue: the extremes are going to hurt people. It’s all going to stay billable hours; it’s all going to go away. Neither is actually the reality.
We need to sit down and do a practice-by-practice-area analysis to say which ones are not going to change for a really long time, and how do we build efficiencies there in client transparency? What are the ones that we should start packaging as an F.A.? And then, from that, how do we have the partnership conversations about fee and value, and how do we develop lawyers in these practice areas versus these? This is deep, deep change management.
Ted: Indeed. Yeah, and, you know, if you look at the AI-native market, it started off very narrowly focused: the Crossbeams, the Garfields, the General Eagles—a really narrow, fairly low-risk, high-volume area of the market. But we are doing high-value work, significantly further up the spectrum from where the first generation—all those firms I named—started out.
And you’re starting to see—I don’t know if you’ve seen Norms, Board of Directors, and, you know, I mean, it’s a really impressive lot. And over time, there’s going to be more Irvings and Norms, and it’s going to force the market. The question is, are big firms going to wait so long that it’s going to be impossible to catch up or not? That’s a really important question.
Libby: Oh God, that’s such a great question, because I’ve just given my intuition as opposed to anything else, which is a wait-and-see profession. This is the one time where it may crush us.
Ted: Yeah. You know, in one of the articles I wrote—I write a series on the future of law—one of the articles is exactly what I’d...
Libby: Everything in our history about waiting, process, delay, discernment—all has worked to our advantage. And now I have a concern that it will work to our disadvantage. We’re not practiced enough at being able to pivot and move, because wait and see, slow and steady, right? Like, you know, always wins the race. And I just don’t know this time that we’re not asleep to that.
My listeners have heard me talk about this before. Not only is everything you’re saying true, there’s an extra, extra dimension to it.
So I know business-of-law professionals who were literally hand-selected for their resistance to change. I have a CIO friend of mine. We have done business with him at three firms, and he has told me verbatim, “Ted, I have two jobs: keep the lights on and spend as little money as possible.”
So basically, the firm lined up their ten shortlist of candidates and said, “Okay, which one of these people is most resistant to change?” “Oh, that one. Let’s make him an offer.”
So not only do you have all of the inherent dynamics in play, but we also have leaders who’ve been hand-selected for their resistance to change. And that is going to have to be addressed.
Now, could you make him—could you turn him around into somebody who embraces change? I don’t know the answer to that. I think it’s going to be harder than maybe making a difficult decision.
I think you hit this earlier in our discussion. The avatar at the top has to be a change-ready leader, right? You cannot ask someone—not that you cannot; I would not expect someone without the authority or the power to be the change initiator, because they’ll get their head chopped off.
I don’t actually blame anybody for following the lingua franca, the language of the day. If we’re a change-resistant place, I stick my neck out, I get fired. I can understand the self-preservation of that, and I actually respect it, which is why I think earlier in the conversation, when you talked about putting together a leadership team capable of ushering in change.
And let’s talk about what change really is, right?
Change is the ability to sit still when things are ugly. It’s this—you talked about resilience. All these words mean the same thing, which is: yes, it’s about to get ugly. Yes, we’re going to have some pain. Yes, people are going to be complaining. We’re going to grit our teeth and go into the sewer anyway.
That’s the right—because the amount of institutional gravity to go back to the way that you vote is going to be so strong, right? That I really do believe that it will have to come from the top.
And I think, you know, if you’re a firm that says, “I hate change,” don’t sign up for leadership. Not in this time, not in this world, because we’re going to get things wrong. And boy, we love to be right.
So, you know, any one of those teams that forms, one of the rules that I give them is, we can’t play the blanking. We have to put that aside right now, because that’s not going to get us where we need to go. We’re going to get half this wrong, right? But we’re going to get half of it right. And that’s—I don’t know if those are the right numbers—but tolerance for imperfection has to go out the window.
Ted: Yeah. Perfectionism will kill.
You know, Clay Christensen, in *The Innovator’s Dilemma*, had a really useful case study for law firms to take note of. In the early 1980s, when IBM was innovating around the PC, they had an existing mainframe business that was very lucrative, and they recognized how difficult it would be to allocate the proper resources and not have stakeholders throwing monkey wrenches.
So they carved out a separate business, isolated it, and allowed that portion of the business to innovate independently. I really think that law firms need to consider that approach when thinking about how to get from A to B.
Libby: That’s what I was talking about. One of the firms I’m working with right now—that’s exactly the activity that we engaged in. We took ten years of data, and we started isolating practice areas that were the most resistant to change and those that were going to be the most open to change. In other words, and then we ranked them.
Then we started to break out what change was going to look like over time and over what period of time, because again, you can’t do everything at once. And so one of the ideas is, honestly, to segment off the things that are going to change and treat them as a revenue line, different from the sort of traditional model we’re going to protect for a while, right?
So that you’re able to innovate where you’re able to innovate, in a segment that doesn’t break your whole machine.
Ted: Right. And I think that’s something that we’re in right now, exactly what you said: a place where we are trying to get ahead where we can and protect what’s not broken.
Libby: But that’s very, very hard, at least from my conversations, just the way that law firms are set up in the partnership model to do, which is hard. I’m not going to lie about that. It’s hard.
Ted: It is, and those with the most influence, to your point, are typically the most senior, with the biggest equity stakes in the business, and they have the loudest voices and the most influence.
Libby: They also have the least economic reasons to adopt a new model. That’s my point.
So I think, again, just calling that out as a fact rather than anything other than that—it is a fact—how do you still get around that, though? How do you—we have to get creative about saying, “Okay, where do we draw the line in the sand?”
Because I think we’re really talking about, and you said it a minute ago, we’re in a very fragmented profession. The winners and the losers are going to start to show themselves.
And by losers, I don’t mean a game that we’re calling out numbers. I mean people lose their jobs. We have a—you know, how do I say this? We have careers that have become affected. This affects human beings, right? It’s not just a—which is what I see a lot of the discussion being, sort of like callous predictions.
But these are human beings’ lives. These are careers. These are my colleagues. I spent 15 years of my life caring for their well-being. It matters to me a lot that we get this right.
And so, in thinking about that, I think it should be much more incumbent upon my generation—the lawyers between the ages of sort of 38 and 55—to really say, “What are we inheriting? What are we going to do about it? And can we form enough creativity that takes care of our more senior partners, but also recognizes they’re not going to be here in the world we’re about to enter?”
I think that’s the kind of business forecasting, that business acumen, that you need to have in leadership right now.
Ted: Indeed, and those aren’t easy discussions.
Well, this has been a fantastic conversation. I knew it would be. I love it. I thank you so much.
Libby: Yeah, no, thank you for taking the time.
Ted: Before we go, how do people find out more about you and the work that you do around attorney wellness?
Libby: Okay, so I have two websites. The law firm is libiclarclah.com. Likewell.org is the dedicated lawyer well-being website. So if you need a firm assessment on well-being, if you want to take a personal assessment, all of those resources are there, and they’re for free. You can access them anytime.
And that is my site with Dr. Cario Harris. So we do a blended program on psychology and law for law firms trying to address what we call existential change management, which is being able to hold both the business and the people that are involved in change.
Ted: Awesome, and we’ll include those links in the show notes.
Libby: Thank you.
Ted: Libby, thanks so much again, and I look forward to meeting you in person real soon.
Libby: It was a pleasure. Thanks so much.
Ted: All right, take care.
Thanks for listening to *Legal Innovations Spotlight*. If you found value in this chat, hit the subscribe button to be notified when we release new episodes.
We’d also really appreciate it if you could take a moment to rate us and leave us a review wherever you’re listening right now.
Your feedback helps us provide you with top-notch content.